Revue française de science politique 61-1, février 2011

L'action publique au prisme de ses instruments
First Edition

Ce numéro témoigne de la multiplication des travaux - francophones et anglo-américains - portant sur la notion d'« instruments de l'action publique » et clarifie cette notion aux contours de plus en plus « élastiques ». Read More

Pierre Lascoumes, Louis Simard
Public policy seen through the prism of its instruments
In recent years, the concepts of "policy tools" and “government technologies” have undergone a marked revival in French-language research. That research is based on an Anglo-American tradition that goes back over 40 years and is now highly diversified, but it has enriched that tradition with various contributions ranging from theories of power to the sociology of science. This paper presents a panorama of the literature in the field, bringing out the diversity of coexisting viewpoints and their development. An instruments-based approach is a good way to track changes in public action, as well as in regimes and political styles. It also conduces to grasping the tangible nature of public action. Understanding instrumentation is a way of comprehending changes in the state by focusing on its practices and reconfigurations, particularly in the ongoing tension between incentives and constraints.

Pauline Ravinet
European coordination alla bolognese
This article deals with the construction of the European Higher Education Area, or the Bologna Process. It uses and discusses an instruments- based approach to retrace in detail the configuration and instrumentation of a European system to coordinate national higher education policies. This approach reveals how what was initially a soft and voluntary process is piloted by means of a cross-sectional tool, namely stocktaking. Furthermore, it aids in characterizing a coordination “à la bolognaise” process that is familiar with “new modes of European governance”, but has a special relation to the European Union, where it has been developed and institutionalised outside the EU institutional framework.

Charlotte Halpern, Patrick Le Galès
No autonomous public policy without ad hoc instruments
This article explores the link between policy instrumentation and policy change at the EU level. It is based on a comparative analysis of policy instruments and their development in European urban and environmental policies. The analysis is based on an original dataset, retracing the evolution of European policy instruments in both areas over the past three decades, and how asks and by whom they were chosen and combined. Challenging the existing literature on new policy instruments and new forms of EU governance, our longitudinal analysis indicates that the traditional focus on new or innovative policy instruments is of limited explanatory power. Our approach shows how EU policies and policy-making are informed by the politics of choice and the combination of policy instruments.

Pierre-Yves Baudot
Uncertain instruments
The reform of administrative computer technology under the French government's Plan Calcul (1966-1975) was not based on a univocal intention or a specific representation of its future effects. Computer technology was not the vector of a single, coherent and stabilized modernization effort. On the contrary, it was introduced as a function of conflicting imperatives. The resources available to the agents of that reform enabled them to assert divergent representations of the tool they were championing. While computer technology altered the connections between them, the impossibility of imposing irreversible decisions bred protracted uncertainty about its real modernizing potentialities and favoured the buildup of incompatible conceptions, which in turn contributed to its spread during that period.

Jean Leca
DEMOCRACIES OUT TO WIN HEARTS AND MINDS IN ASYMMETRICAL WARS.
GENERAL PROBLEMS AND SPECIFIC HISTORICAL SITUATIONS

The book reviewed here treats of the Israeli-Palestinian military problem as a particular case of the general question of democracies faced with the dilemmas of “counter-insurgency”. Combining Raymond Aron's realistic approach and Michael Walzer's ethical approach, the author recommends a different military policy : one that is guided by “empathy”, acknowledging the Palestinians' suffering and at least the partial validity of their demands, and by “schizophrenia”, pursuing at once the eradication of armed groups and support for civilian populations. This appeal to reason based on “short-term history” (1980-2010) may well overlook the uniqueness of a conflict in which “current events hark back in time” and in which “long[er]-term history” (1920-2010) shows the primacy of “overarching narratives” whose acceptance is a prerequisite for the rational games they authorize. In this case, Zahal's strategic dilemma becomes the Israeli state's political dilemma: to avoid both “hostile empathy” and “defeatist sympathy”.


Paperback - In French 23.00 €

InfoPlease note - orders will resume shipping from Monday August 17

Specifications


Publisher
Presses de Sciences Po
Author
,
Journal
Revue française de science politique
ISSN
00352950
Language
French
BISAC Subject Heading
POL000000 POLITICAL SCIENCE
Onix Audience Codes
06 Professional and scholarly
CLIL (Version 2013-2019)
3283 SCIENCES POLITIQUES
Title First Published
01 February 2011
Subject Scheme Identifier Code
Thema subject category: Politics & government

Paperback


Publication Date
01 February 2011
ISBN-13
978-27246-3229-3
Extent
Main content page count : 200
Code
9782724632293
Dimensions
16 x 24 x 1 cm
Weight
292 grams
List Price
23.00 €
ONIX XML
Version 2.1, Version 3

Google Book Preview


Contents


ARTICLES
L'action publique au prisme de ses instruments
Introduction
Pierre Lascoumes, Louis Simard

La coordination européenne « à la bolognaise »
Réflexions sur l’instrumentation de l’Espace européen d’enseignement supérieur
Pauline Ravinet

Pas d’action publique autonome sans instruments propres
Analyse comparée et longitudinale des politiques environnementales et urbaines de l’Union européenne
Charlotte Halpern, Patrick Le Galès

L’incertitude des instruments
L’informatique administrative et le changement dans l’action publique (1966-1975)
Pierre-Yves Baudot

CONTROVERSE
Les démocraties à la conquête des âmes dans les guerres asymétriques
Problèmes généraux et situations historiques singulières
Jean Leca

CHRONIQUE BIBLIOGRAPHIQUE : EN-DEÇÀ ET AU-DELÀ DU VOTE

LECTURES CRITIQUES
The American Voter revisité
Jean-Gabriel Contamin

« Guerres culturelles » et réalignement électoral dans un système partisan semi-décentralisé
Simon Labouret

Partis indianistes et gouvernement local, une approche de la démocratie participative
Camille Goirand

Les mutations du champ de la représentation syndicale
Baptiste Giraud

COMPTES RENDUS
Nonna Mayer, Sociologie des comportements politiques
Loïc Blondiaux

Alan Renwick, The Politics of Electoral Reform. Changing the Rules of Democracy
Louis Massicotte

Jean-Benoît Pilet, Changer pour gagner ? Les réformes des lois électorales en Belgique
Bernard Dolez

Erik S. Herron, Elections and Democracy after Communism ?
Filip Kostelka

Mikhail Myagkov, Peter C. Ordeshook, Dimitri Shakin, The Forensics of Election Fraud. Russia and Ukraine
Nathalie Dompnier

Renée Dickason, David Haigron, Karine Rivière-de Franco (dir.), Stratégies et campagnes électorales en Grande-Bretagne et aux États-Unis
Jacques Gerstlé

Michael Bruter, Sarah Harrison, The Future of our Democracies. Young Party Members in Europe
Céline Belot

Lucie Bargel, Jeunes socialistes, jeunes UMP. Lieux et processus de socialisation politique
Florence Haegel, Manon Réguer-Petit

Anne Muxel, Avoir 20 ans en politique. Les enfants du désenchantement
Bernard Fournier

Orit Kedar, Voting for Policy, not Parties. How Voters Compensate for Power Sharing
Nicolas Sauger

Stuart N. Soroka, Christopher Wlezien, Degrees of Democracy. Politics, Public Opinion, and Policy
Vincent Tiberj

Bernard Pudal, Un monde défait. Les communistes français de 1956 à nos jours
Catherine Leclercq

Denis Merklen, Quartiers populaires, quartiers politiques
Nathalie Fuchs

Cécile Péchu, Les squats
Bénédicte Havard Duclos

Xavier Crettiez, Laurent Mucchielli (dir.), Les violences politiques en Europe. Un état des lieux
Philippe Braud

Eduardo Silva, Challenging Neoliberalism in Latin America
David Garibay

Elizabeth F. Cohen, Semi-Citizenship in Democratic Politics
Camille Hamidi

REVUE DES REVUES

RÉSUMÉS, ABSTRACTS